Ukugcinwa kwesango emthonjeni ovulekile: isiko, amacala, amaqhinga kanye nokuphuma

Abalandeli Abakwe-Inthanethi » Amanethiwekhi omphakathi » Ukugcinwa kwesango emthonjeni ovulekile: isiko, amacala, amaqhinga kanye nokuphuma

Eminyakeni yakamuva, igama elithi ukugcinwa kwesango liye langena kuzo zonke izingxoxo mayelana nesofthiwe yamahhala nemiphakathi yezobuchwepheshe. Asikhulumi nje ngezihlungi zobuchwepheshe.kodwa kunalokho izinqumo zamasiko, ezenhlalo, futhi ngokuvamile ezomnotho ezinqumayo ukuthi ubani ongena, ubani onikelayo, futhi imiphi imibono echumayo ku-ecosystem. Phakathi kokuchichima kwamakhosombe kanye nengcindezi yekhwalithi, abantu abaningi babona ukungqubuzana okudlula ikhodi ngokwayo.

Lo mbhalo uhlanganisa izimo zangempela, ukuhlaziya okubucayi neziphakamiso zokunciphisa izithiyo, kuyilapho kuhlolwa “umgcini-sango” ohluke kakhulu: isistimu engaphansi yokuqinisekisa ye-Android. Inhloso ikabili.Ukuhlela inkulumo-mpikiswano ehluka kakhulu futhi, ngesikhathi esifanayo, ukunikeza amathuluzi asebenzayo okuphatha, umphakathi kanye nenqubo yenqubo ekhuthaza ukufakwa ngaphandle kokudela amazinga.

Yini esiyiqondayo ngokugcina isango emthonjeni ovulekile namuhla?

Ukuqhuma kwamaphrojekthi omthombo ovulekile kulethe indida: amakhosombe ayanda, kodwa hhayi njalo izinga nokugcinwa kwawo. Abizwa ngokuthi "amaphrojekthi we-slop" Lokhu kubhekisela ezinhlelweni ezikha phezulu ezinamadokhumenti amancane, ukuzinikela okuphansi, noma izindlela ezidlulayo ezethula umsindo nokudideka. Kubasunguli namaqembu, ukuhlukanisa isiginali emsindweni kudla isikhathi futhi kwehlisa ukwethembana.

Izingozi zale khwalithi ephansi zisobala: ukukhathala komphakathi, izinqumo ezingalungile zobuchwepheshe, kanye nokuntuleka kokubonakala kwamaphrojekthi abalulekile ngempela. Lapho yonke into ibonakala ilinganaIzinyathelo ezicatshangelwe kahle zicwiliswa phakathi kwama-clones, ukulahlwa, kanye nokuhlolwa okuphekwe kancane, futhi ukutholwa kuba okokugcina.

Ukulinganisela vs nokugcinwa kwesango: izinhlaka ezimbili zamasiko eziphikisanayo

Ezingeni lamasiko, kubalulekile ukuhlukanisa phakathi kokulinganisela nokugcinwa kwesango. Umlindisango “uvikela isango” Futhi iyingxenye yokunqatshelwa okuzenzakalelayo: ivikela ukufinyelela okukhawulelwe, idinga imininingwane, futhi isebenza ngokohlelo. Ngokuphambene, ukulinganisela kuthatha ukuvuleleka futhi kwenza ngokumelene nokuziphatha okungcolisa indawo evamile.

Umehluko ongokoqobo uyabonakala: ukulinganisela kufuna ukufakwa kanye nokuphilisana, kuyilapho ukugcinwa kwesango kuthanda ukukhishwa, ngisho okuzenzakalelayo futhi ngaphandle kwama-nuances. Umongameli udinga ukwahlulela nokuxhumana nabantu Ukuxhuma ithalente, hhayi ukulihambisa ngomnyango owodwa. Izinga lokushintshana, hhayi igunya, isilinganiso sempumelelo.

Okuhlangenwe nakho kwangempela kokukhishwa kanye nezihlungi zomphakathi

Icala lakamuva elibikiwe emphakathini okhuluma isiNgisi: unjiniyela ushicilele iphrojekthi yetheminali ku-/r/opensource enelayisensi ye-AGPL 3.0, elungiselelwe ngokuzenzakalela i-OpenAI kodwa ehambisana namanye amamodeli, okuhlanganisa amamodeli avuliwe. Okuthunyelwe kuvinjwe ngokuzenzakalela ukuze kukhulunywe "i-OpenAI", futhi omengameli bayihlukanise ngokuthi "i-ChatGPT wrapper", into enqatshelwe imithetho yabo yangaphakathi, nakuba ingazange ibekwe ngokucacile emithethweni yomphakathi ye-sub.

Ngemva kwengxoxo elinganiselwe, impendulo yathi "isebenza njengokuhlosiwe," iphikisana ngokuthi "ukukhangisa" i-OpenAI iphikisana "nomoya we-FOSS." Umbhali ubuze ngesikhalo sokuqhathanisa. ngamaphrojekthi ahlanganisa ubuchwepheshe bobunikazi (i-macOS, iWindows, i-AWS, i-GitHub), kodwa ayitholanga ncazelo. Umphumela: ukungakhululeki kanye nomuzwa wokuthi, kweminye imibuthano, isihlungi singokwengqondo kunesobuchwepheshe.

Amaqhinga okugcina atholwe kumaphrojekthi we-FLOSS

Ukungenelela kwamathimba asebenzisekayo kumaphrojekthi ahlukahlukene omthombo ovulekile kubhale amaqhinga avelayo “okuhlunga” iminikelo yangaphandle. Amaphethini amathathu akhonjiweUkungaphenduli, ukukhishwa inyumbazane, nokwamukela okungamanga akukhona okuhlukile; bavela emiphakathini eyahlukene enamandla afanayo.

• Ayikho impendulo: imibiko neziphakamiso ezinemininingwane aziphendulwa.
• Ukungabandakanywa komphakathi: iminikelo ivunyelwe, kodwa umuntu ukhishwa inyumbazane ohlelweni lwangempela lokuthatha izinqumo.
• Ukwamukela okungamanga: ushintsho luhlanganisiwe, kodwa ngokuhamba kwesikhathi othile osesikhundleni uyaluhlehlisa ngaphandle kwenkulumo-mpikiswano.

Ezimweni ezimbalwa (“A”, “D” kanye “F”), amaqembu e-HCI athumele ukuhlolwa kwe-heuristic, ama-walkthrough, ukuhlolwa kwabasebenzisi kanye nama-interface prototypes. Azikho izimpendulo ezisebenzayoFuthi bekungekho izinguquko ezibangelwa imiphumela. Ngisho noma umphakathi uthi “sakuxoxile ngaphakathi,” awukho umkhondo wokulandelela noma ukuhlanganisa.

Ukukhishwa inyumbazane emphakathini kubonakale kumaphrojekthi anezigaba eziphawuliwe kanye "nomashiqela onomusa" ongafinyeleleki. Imibiko yamukelekile futhi inkhulumomphendvulwano iyakhuthazwa. ku-IRC noma izinkundla, kodwa iziphakamiso azingeni ohlelweni lomsebenzi noma ezintweni ezibalulekile zesenzo sokulungisa. Ngenxa yokuthi abafinyeleli esiteshini sangempela esithatha izinqumo, umnikelo uyahlanjululwa.

Ukwamukelwa okungelona iqiniso bekumangalisa kakhulu: umnikelo wokufundisa oklanywe kabusha, wavivinywa nabasebenzisi futhi wabungazwa ngokuzibophezela okubhekisela kumbiko, wagcina ngokuthi ubuyiselwe ngokuphelele umlobi wawo wokuqala. Ngaphandle kwengxoxo evulekile noma ukuvumelanaUshintsho lubuyele esimweni salo sangaphambilini; okunye ukuthuthukiswa kwangaphambilini nakho kwaqedwa ngokuhamba kwesikhathi.

Ivula kanjani iminyango: ukugibela, ukuqondisa, kanye namamethrikhi

Ukunciphisa izithiyo zokungena kudinga izinqubo, hhayi nje umusa. Amadokhumenti atholakalayo Ngemihlahlandlela esheshayo, "izinkinga zokuqala," indawo ekwazi ukukhiqizwa kabusha, nezifanekiso ze-PR, ukukhathazeka kokuqaliswa kuyancipha. Uma isikhathi sokuhlanganisa kokuqala sincipha, ukugcinwa kuyanda.

Izinhlelo zokweluleka zesikhashana (amaqembu, amahora okusebenza, izinhlelo zabangane) zisebenza lapho zihleliwe futhi zixhunyaniswa nezinjongo ezicacile. Imiphumela elinganisekayo ihlanganisa Izinga eliphezulu lama-PR amukelwayo avela kubabhali abasha, iziphindaphindo ezimbalwa ngesibuyekezo ngasinye, futhi, ezinsukwini ezingu-90, ukusebenzisana okuphindayo okwengeziwe. Ukungafihli emithethweni, ama-SLA okuphendula, kanye nemibandela yezinqumo kunciphisa umuzwa wokungakhethi.

Enye "Umgcini-sango": ukufakazela ubuqiniso bephasiwedi ku-Android

Ku-Android, i-Gatekeeper iwuhlelo olungaphansi kwezokuphepha olungahlangene ngalutho nesiko lomphakathi. Umgomo wabo uwukuqinisekisa amaphethini/amaphasiwedi ngokhiye abasekelwa izingxenyekazi zekhompuyutha ku-TEE (Indawo Ethembekile Yokusebenzisa), khipha amathokheni okuqinisekisa futhi usebenzise “ukucindezela” ngokumelene nokuhlasela kwendluzula.

Isakhiwo sihlanganisa izingxenye ezintathu: i-daemon "yomgcini-sango" (isevisi ye-Binder AIDL ene-platform-agnostic logic), isevisi ye-HAL yomthengisi esebenzisa i-"IGatekeeper", kanye ne-Trusted Application ku-TEE eqhuba ukuqinisekiswa kwangempela. Ukugeleza okuvamile kuhilela leyo LockSettingsService eyibiza ngokuthi "umlindisango", obiza i-HAL, futhi, i-TA evikelekile.

Ukusetshenziswa kufanele kuhambisane nefomethi ye-"HardwareAuthToken" evamile futhi kudalule izindlela "zokubhalisa" kanye "nokuqinisekisa". "Bhalisa" kusayina ukuqinisekisa futhi ibuyisela isibambo esinesakhiwo esichaziwe; "qinisekisa" uqhathanisa isiginesha ekhiqiziwe nesibambo esigciniwe. Ukhiye wesiginesha akumele ushintshe futhi kufanele utholakale ekuqaliseni ngakunye.

Nge-Trusty (i-TEE OS ye-Google evulekile) imfihlo yabiwa phakathi kwe-KeyMint kanye ne-Gatekeeper ukuze kusayinwe i-AuthTokens ku-Keystore, ngaphandle kokuphikelela. Iphasiwedi ye-HMAC ihlala kuMgcini-sango kuphelaUkusebenzisa i-Android evamile ye-C++ kwenza kube lula ukuthumela ku-TEE yenkampani yangaphandle, inqobo nje uma i-IGatekeeper ithotshelwa futhi ukhiye we-HMAC wabelwe ne-KeyMint ngaphansi kwesiteshi esivikelekile.

Ama-SID omsebenzisi (omazisi be-TEE bangaphakathi) akhiqizwa lapho kubhaliswa igama-mfihlo elisha ngaphandle kwedlule (ukubhaliswa kabusha okungathenjwa) futhi ayalondolozwa lapho kushintshwa nedlule evumelekile (ukubhaliswa kabusha okuthenjiwe). I-SID ihamba nge-HardwareAuthToken futhi ihlobanise okhiye be-Keystore nalobo bunikazi. Ukubhaliswa kabusha okungathenjwa kwenza okhiye abaxhunyiwe bangasebenzi, okwandisa izindleko zokuhlasela nge-OS eyonakele.

Ngokunciphisa amandla, u-Gatekeeper ubhala izinto zokubala zokwehluleka ngaphambi kokuhlola, ahlanze impumelelo, futhi ahloniphe ukuphela kwesikhathi esibuyiselwe kuklayenti. Uma kunesitoreji esivikelekileKunconywa ukuphikelela counter; Uma kungenjalo, sebenzisa i-RPMB. Kubalulekile ukuthi iwashi elivikelekile libe elimnandi futhi "ithikithi" limiswe okwesikhashana.

Lapho ingqalasizinda isetshenziswa njengesikhali

Ngale kwekhodi, ukulawulwa kwezingqalasizinda ezibalulekile (amakhosombe, ukusatshalaliswa, izandiso) sekuyinsika yokuncintisana. Amacala amabili aphakamise izinhlabamkhosi emphakathini: imikhawulo ku-ecosystem ye-WordPress kanye nezinguquko kuzandiso ze-VS Code ngokumelene nokusabalaliswa okuhambisanayo njenge-Cursor.

Kwa-WordPress, kubikwe ukuthi umphathi wekhosombe osemthethweni uvimbele ukufinyelela emitatsheni yolwazi nezibuyekezo ezizenzakalelayo, okuthinta amasayithi ayizigidi eziyi-1,5 futhi kwadalula igagasi lokugxekwa, ukwesula kwangaphakathi, kanye nokumangalelwa. Umbono womphakathi wawunjalo ukuthi umuntu oqhudelana naye wayejeziswa ngemithetho engacacile, elimaza ukwethenjwa ekubuseni.

Emkhathini we-VS Code, ama-plugin athile aqale ukwenqaba ukusebenza uma engakutholi ukusatshalaliswa "koqobo", ngemuva nje kokuthi i-Cursor iphumile. Ukulungiswa okubhekiselwe “ekuzizwinisweni okungaguquki”Kodwa-ke, isikhathi sahunyushwa njengokungaboni ngasolinye futhi okuphambene nokuncintisana yizinkulungwane zonjiniyela abasekela ukuhamba kwabo komsebenzi ohlelweni lwezandiso lwe-ecosystem.

Inkontileka yezenhlalakahle, ukubusa nezinye izindlela zobuchwepheshe

Lapho okulindelwe ukuzinza kwephulwa, ukuhlukana nokuphindaphindwa kwemizamo kuyavela. Isixazululo esivuthiwe sihilela Hlukanisa ingqalasizinda kwezithakazelo zezentengiso ngokusebenzisa izisekelo ezinokumelwa kobuningi (Linux Foundation, ASF, CNCF), ukushicilela izinqubomgomo zokufinyelela, shintsha umnqamulajuqu nezinqubo zezikhalazo.

Ngokuhambisanayo, amamodeli asabalalisiwe (isb., iziphakamiso ze-P2P ezifana ne-Radicle) ziyakhula ukuze zisuse amaphuzu owodwa okulawula. Abakabi iningiKodwa bakhomba indlela: ukuqina lapho bebhekene nemikhawulo ehlangene nemithetho eshintsha phakathi nomdlalo.

Emaqenjini nezinkampani, kuyatuseka ukuhlola ubungozi bokuncika: ubani olawula iziteshi, umlando wezinguquko zenqubomgomo, eminye imizila, kanye nokungqubuzana kwezintshisekelo zezentengiso. Hlukanisa futhi ugcine izinhlelo zezimo eziphuthumayo Manje isiyingxenye yomklamo wezakhiwo, hhayi ukunethezeka.

Indida yokuvula: kungani kwesinye isikhathi kufanele uvale

Umbono owodwa osikiselayo ulinganisa “Indida Yokuvuleleka” nekaPopper ethi “Indida Yokubekezelelana”: ukuze kugcinwe ukuvuleka, ngezinye izikhathi kuyadingeka ukuba ikhiphe imikhuba eyibhubhisayo. I-Ostrom kanye nethiyori ye-commons Banikeza isiqondiso esisebenzayo: ukuchaza imikhawulo, ukuqapha ukusetshenziswa, ukuhlukumeza okujezisayo, nokulungisa imithetho endaweni.

Kusetshenziswa endaweni yedatha ne-AI, "ukuvulwa ngenjongo yokuvula" kungasiza ukuthwebula okukhulu okuyimfihlo kanye nezindawo ezivalekile. Ingaphezu "kwedatha yezimiso zokuziphatha"Sidinga idatha evulekile ngaphansi kwemigomo eshiwo umphakathi, enezikhungo ezilawula ukufinyelela, ukusetshenziswa kocwaningomabhuku kanye nokusabalalisa izinzuzo (isb., amamodeli “edatha yomphakathi”).

Kubalulekile futhi ukucabanga ukuthi ukufinyelela okusebenzayo kudlulela ngalé kwelungelo elingokomthetho nje. Ingabe inkundla ingaziba izinhlawulo? Futhi ukuze uqhubeke nokukhipha inani, ukuphoqelela kuza sekwephuze kakhulu. Yingakho ukwakha izingqalasizinda kanye nemithethonqubo ekwazi ukukhipha labo abephula umthetho igwema "ukuyilandela" ngokuhamba kwesikhathi.

Umthombo ovulekile vs i-AI evaliwe: impikiswano evuthayo

Ku-AI, ukungqubuzana phakathi kokuvuleleka nokulawulwa kwenkampani kubhekene ngqo. Kuye kwenziwa izimpikiswano ezehlisa inani lomthombo ovulekile kumamodeli amakhulu, kubalula ukushoda kwezindleko zomphakathi ezinikelayo kanye nencazelo. Ebhekene nalokhu, amazwi avelele Baveza ukuthi ukuvuleka kwenza kube lula ukuhlela kahle, ukutolika, kanye nokuthunyelwa kokusabalalisa okungenakwenzeka ngamabhokisi amnyama.

Amacala azungeza kunkulumo-mpikiswano abonisa amaqembu amancane afinyelela izilinganiso ezibalulekile emavikini, ngamamodeli omthombo ovulekile asuka kwimvelaphi ehlukahlukene (okuhlanganisa ne-China) aqhudelana nezinye izindlela zobunikazi ngezindleko eziphansi. Izifundo ze-Macroeconomic zihambisana nesofthiwe yamahhala inani elikhulu lezomnotho maqondana nokutshalwa kwezimali kwayo okuqondile.

Izimpendulo zomphakathi ezivela ku-ecosystem (Hugging Face, abacwaningi, izibalo ezifana ne-LeCun noma i-Zuckerberg) zixhumanisa ukuvuleka nokuvikeleka, ukusebenza kanye nobukhosi bezobuchwepheshe, futhi zixwayise mayelana ubungozi bokugxilisa i-AI ezandleni ezimbalwa. Ukushuba kwesimo kuphinde kudlulele emkhakheni wezomthetho: amacala ngamasethi edatha nezincwadi ezisetshenziswa ekuqeqesheni adalule izikhala zokuthobela kanye nokwenza izinto obala.

Mayelana nezindleko zokucatshangelwa, labo abamele amanethiwekhi ahlukaniselwe amazwe baphikisa ngokuthi ukuncintisana phakathi kwamanethiwekhi angaphansi akhethekile kunciphisa amanani futhi kuthuthukise ikhwalithi. "Ukuxhumana kwama-subnets" Futhi amamodeli okubhida aguqukayo abonisa ukuthi imakethe nokuvuleleka kungaqondanisa izisusa lapho ingqalasizinda ingathunjwa.

Yini ehlukanisa iphrojekthi enhle ye-FOSS

Kunezici ezihlukanisa amaphrojekthi asimeme nomsindo: ukubeka izinto obala kanye nezimiso zokuziphatha (imithetho ecacile, amalayisensi angashintshi, ukuhlonipha umphakathi), imibhalo ewusizo kanye nokugibela, ukuxhumana okuvulekile kanye nempendulo ngaphandle kwezigaba, nokuzibophezela okuqhubekayo okungaphezu "kokwethulwa nokukhohlwa." Lezi zimfanelo zinciphisa isidingo ukugcinwa kwesango okuzivikela, ngoba isistimu igawula okokufaka ngaphandle kokulahlekelwa yikhwalithi.

• Ukungafihli kanye nokunikezwa kwelayisensi kuhambisana namagugu nenjongo.
• Ukuvuleka enemihlahlandlela, indawo ekwazi ukukhiqizwa kabusha, nezinkinga zomnikelo wokuqala.
• Impendulo eyakhayo kanye nemithetho yokubuyekeza ebikezelwe.
• Isondlo kanye nokubusa okungancikile kumaqhawe odwa.

Izimiso zokuziphatha nokusimama

Inkulumompikiswano ngamalayisensi “ezimiso zokuziphatha” kanye nokusimama kwemizamo yomphakathi isalokhu ivulekile. Okwabasunguli namaqembuUkukhetha ngokuhlakanipha noma ukunikela ngokucabangisisa kuhlanganisa ukuhlola isici somuntu: ukubuyisana, ukubusa, kanye nomthwalo wemfanelo wesikhathi eside. Ukukhetha okuhle konga ubuhlungu futhi kwakha nokuqina.

Ukwehlukanisa ukulawulwa kwengqalasizinda nokulawulwa kwebhizinisi, izinqubo zokushintsha imithetho yokushicilela, ukunikeza izwi kulabo abathintekile, nokugwema ukuvinjwa okungosomathuba kubalulekile uma silangazelela indawo evundile. Ukuvuleleka kuyachuma uma kukhona ukwethembanaFuthi ukwethembana kutshalwa ngemithetho ecacile, inkumbulo yesikhungo, nokunakekelana.

Imithombo nokufundwa kwereferensi

Ezinye izinto ezicashuniwe noma ezishiwo kulokhu kubuka konke zandisa ingxoxo ngolwazi, izinhlaka, nezimo ezithile. Ukuzihlola kuyasiza ukwenza kube yingqikithi yamaqhinga okugcina, ukubusa, nemithelela yomphakathi:

1. iphrojekthi-yakho-inzima
2. Inkulumompikiswano ku-HN
3. I-post-open-source
4. Gcina i-podcast
5. Iforamu ye-EEVblog
6. umbono wakho-uyamangaza

Ngaphezu kwe-dichotomy elula yokuthi "i-open vs. close," okuvelayo isidingo sezikhungo, izinqubo, nesiko elisivumela ukuthi sihehe ithalente ngaphandle kokucupha noma ubani, ngezivikelo ekubanjweni, kanye nengqalasizinda engeke yaphendulwa kithi. Ikhwalithi yekhodi ibalulekile, kodwa kanjalo nokuphatha. Yikhona okunqumayo ukuthi inzuzo evamile iyakhula, ihlukana kabili ngenxa yokungathembani, noma ihlale isezandleni zanoma ubani onyakazisa amapali uma kumfanele.